Forum - View topicHow to Submit Series Relations.
Goto page Previous Next |
Author | Message | ||
---|---|---|---|
Calathan
Subscriber
Posts: 9113 |
|
||
That name sounds good to me. |
|||
Calathan
Subscriber
Posts: 9113 |
|
||
I submitted this before, but it got lost in the downtime. Lupin III vs. Detective Conan The Movie is currently linked as just "related" to Lupin III vs. Detective Conan (special) without any specific relation given. I've watched both of them now, and the movie is an actual sequel to the special.
|
|||
ANN_Lynzee
ANN Executive Editor
Posts: 3006 Location: Email for assistance only |
|
||
Thanks. I've fixed it again.
|
|||
Calathan
Subscriber
Posts: 9113 |
|
||
Thank you for fixing that again. If you have time, there are still a lot of older posts from this thread that haven't been acted on. I think my oldest post that wasn't acted on is from 2009, but there might be some that are even older from other people. Here is a summary of everything I've submitted in this thread that I don't think has been acted on yet: Post 1 - Linking Nakoruru (OAV) to the rest of the Samurai Shodown franchise. I'm thinking now that just linking it as "related" to the movie might work. Post 2 - Linking Leina: Wolf Sword Legend and Lightning Trap - Leina & Laika to the Machine Robo franchise. Dormcat replied about this at some point, but didn't link them up because neither of us knew the exact relationship to the rest of the franchise. However, it has been 5 years, and since they definitely are related, I think it is better to just link them with the "related" relationship than to leave them separated from the rest of the franchise forever. I think just linking both of them as related to Machine Robo: Revenge of Chronos would be best. Post 3 - Linking Street Fighter IV: The Ties That Bind (OAV) to the rest of the Street Fighter franchise. There also is now a Super Street Fighter IV (OAV) that isn't linked with the rest of the franchise. A lot of the Street Fighter franchise is just linked as "related" to each other, with the Street Fighter II movie at the base of the relationship links. However, I think it would probably make more sense to have an anthology entry for the Street Fighter franchise, and to remove those "related" links when there isn't any specific relation other than being part of the Street Fighter franchise. The Street Fighter IV entries could then be added to the anthology entry. Post 4 - Kimagure Orange Road (OAV) is currently listed as a sequel to Kimagure Orange Road: The Movie, but that relationship isn't right. Plot-wise, the movie has to happen later than the OAVs. A bunch of people replied to my post, and I think the general consensus was that the OAVs should be linked as a side-story to the TV series. The first movie would then be a sequel of the TV series, and the second movie should probably be a sequel of the first movie (with neither linking directly to the OAVs). Post 5 - Linking Jankenman (TV) and Jankenman: Kaijudaikessen (OAV). I think the OAV is probably a side-story of the TV series, but I haven't watched either. Post 6 - Anime V Comic Rentaman should be changed into an anthology entry, since it was 4 separate anime released together (and each of those 4 has its own encyclopedia page already). Post 7 - Linking up the parts of the Kobo-chan franchise. |
|||
ANN_Lynzee
ANN Executive Editor
Posts: 3006 Location: Email for assistance only |
|
||
Took care of all the posts with the exception of Anime V Comic Rentaman because I haven't done anthology stuff before. Same goes with the anthology for Street Fighter but I did link the loose OAVs to Street Fighter II the Movie.
I was wondering if the two Street Fighter IV OAVs were also linked in some way however? If so, I could add that relationship as well. All the Kobo-chan specials were linked as adaptations of the manga but I can change this if anyone has more information. |
|||
Calathan
Subscriber
Posts: 9113 |
|
||
Thank you for taking care of all of those.
I haven't seen the Street Fighter IV OAVs, so I don't know if they are related to each other beyond being adapted from the same game. |
|||
Elli21486
Posts: 2 |
|
||
I just finished watching Seitokai Yakuindomo* (TV) and noticed that the anime continues beyond that with OAV's. There is no section sections regarding the OAVs as they will be under Seitokai Yakuindomo*(OAV). As of now, there are 3 OAV for Seitokai Yakuindomo* that continues after with a reported 4th OAV coming out in, I believe, July 2015.
|
|||
Calathan
Subscriber
Posts: 9113 |
|
||
Elli21486, if the new OAVs don't have an entry in the encyclopedia yet, you should submit them at animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/new-anime.php. This thread is supposed to be for linking things that already do have entries in the encyclopedia.
|
|||
Chibi Shoujo
Posts: 97 Location: Wisconsin, USA |
|
||
These two manga need to be fixed:
manga#16949 manga#11678 "Ookami ga Kuru!" was the original story published in 2006, making "Shinyaku Ōkami ga Kuru!" the sequel published in 2008, not that the former is a prequel. Also, "Ookami ga Kuru" should be set to "serialized in [Comic Rush]" like the sequel, and then I believe the comment on the Vintage section for both entries can be removed since it would be redundant. |
|||
ANN_Lynzee
ANN Executive Editor
Posts: 3006 Location: Email for assistance only |
|
||
Fixed the sequel-prequel thing.
I'm not entirely sure how the anthologies should work. Personally, I wish that the "serialized in Comic Rush" at the top was only for current series, so you could click on it and see what's currently in the magazine. Meanwhile adding it after the vintage for finished series still keeps the information useful. Otherwise we get these magazine anthologies that are just giant lists. But I'm not 100% on what the intent is. |
|||
Shiroi Hane
Encyclopedia Editor
Posts: 7580 Location: Wales |
|
||
I believe it is important to record both what magazine a title was serialised in, and conversely to be able to see a list of titles that were seralised in a particular magazine, but they can get a little unwieldy in the current form.
There has been staff discussion in the past on whether to use anthologies or company entries for this purpose. If you want clarity you can try raising it in the staff forum (or bump this); the closest I've found to a current ruling is the relationship guidelines (although I may just be looking in the wrong places). |
|||
ECW28
Posts: 72 |
|
||
Shouldn't Naruto Shippuden be listed as adapted from Naruto (manga)?
|
|||
dormcat
Encyclopedia Editor
Posts: 9902 Location: New Taipei City, Taiwan, ROC |
|
||
Being a direct sequel of Naruto (TV), it is not necessary to do so. |
|||
nobahn
Subscriber
Posts: 5139 |
|
||
I am unable to find an entry for Kamisama Kiss Kako-hen. There is an entry for a 2013 OAV.
|
|||
SupaMika Mikarin
Posts: 2 |
|
||
Tokyo Ghoul:re (manga) (#16317) is listed as a spinoff of Tokyo Ghoul (manga) (#16086), this is incorrect, it's a sequel.
Tokyo Ghoul √A (TV) (#16318) is listed as a sequel on the page for the Tokyo Ghoul (manga), when it would be more accurate to list it as a spinoff (with regards to the manga) given that it's an alternate continuity from the manga's. |
|||
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
||
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group