Forum - View topic

Manga Publishing Houses, Raw Scanlators, Mangaka

In this year's 20th issue of Shueisha's Weekly Shonen Jump magazine on Monday, the editors are publishing an open letter about unauthorized online copies of manga. The editors say that unauthorized copying and uploading are against the wishes of the manga creators. They also emphasize that "the unauthorized online copies do harm to the manga culture, the manga creators' rights, and above all, the manga creators' spirits." They acknowledge that the amount of unauthorized copying has become so overwhelming that they are unable to deal with all of it.

The editors ask their readers to realize that all unauthorized copying and uploading is illegal. They add that manga creators and Shueisha will be dealing severely with unauthorized copies on the Internet, and the editors ask for the readers' support.

In another development, the raw-paradise.com website, which hosted scanned copies of manga magazines without permission, currently redirects to Shueisha's website.

Thanks to Starks for the news tip.

Simple as this, if stop reading onl the popularity of the manga will be down very low, because thanks to the web community to know that reading manga, and separate collection doang if that is a good translation and quality in the whole of the Japanese style, fans what type to buy support, especially OP, reading onl is not really so little money does not buy.

If the author or the mangaka is able to support, but if the readers are opposed.
Onl views is regarded as a manga of the poor, while increasing the price series, economic crisis spread, unemployment bla bla bla ... seriously If buying series of dc publishers but also the first half last year .. die set.

Manga is the birth right to read the first author known as much before because the new measure than sitting there like that have been mentioned test must purchase by readers restrict competition contrary results alone, only thinking of ear own immediate prestige it will obscure the future.

There are sure you like Kim Dong then we never enthusiasts and One Piece.

There are publishers that produce manga in English Vietnamese Vietnamese, more than we were bored One Piece right from the first book then.

========

Consider those who have never read One Piece, which started right away ... Kim Dong is a translation of a sentence has commented: "I've read do not understand!

========

About the Publisher in Japan ...

They must have thought something bad about this ... If successful, after some well-known series such This will only ... also popular in Japan ....

The warning that should also be part ... But demolish a site like it seems ... unstable.

Weekly Shounen Jump magazine is published in Naruto, Bleach and One Piece (besides Bakuman, Reborn!, Gintama, HunterxHunter) weekly. This means that if this letter caused great influence scan raw manga fans out there, they will not continue to scan again, which means the last chapter of the shounen manga is almost the hottest now will disappear completely Internet

Worse, who will no longer scan raw manga well again, until then, so you only read the manga is the only way to buy directly in Japan or read a translation of the publisher Vietnam.

This is possible because the manga is a scan of unlawful actions. Go against the interests of the author ... and harmful to the Japanese comics industry (sales falling, a part of illegal scans by the internet).
This letter not only urged fans to stop scanning of the WSJ story, which is generally active scan for all manga. As I know, so far without any manga magazines or stand out this public call for all Does anyone know any case in history is not similar?

Changes in this case it is difficult to predict, because there are opponents (the fans outside of Japan), people have not (who spends money to buy manga, or who is considered pro-protection-of-the-industry -story-competition).

- Advantages:
1. The industry will develop more manga, manga will be more than you were - higher revenues.
If no floating manga online, publishers may be thinking about Vietnam bought the rights of the hot and publish them weekly, but if as now, online service that is full of stories to read. .., does not necessarily need to publishers.

Prodigy example of Vietnam - has just published the 4th day was the 5th Vietnamese scans on your internet, you have to buy again? Unless you're rich, then do not say.

2. Rights guaranteed by the author.

- Disability points:
1. Limit the amount of exposure to manga fans. Increasingly, the popularity of manga will be lower due to popular liberty. Since it also leads to lower worldwide sales, because people know there even scans the internet, but they still spends money to buy manga for fans.

The disability points of this so big, because I think that if the internet is not being released to the Japanese comics can not always popular and so many fans.

Much influence here
Then the mangaka or publishers have forgotten why and how the birth manga
Is to bring joy to others
I hate the cheap they tear Publisher Thanh Hoa Dong Nai ... publishers do not buy pirated copyright and publishing money
But you yourself who are passionate about trans manga manga for people to share
Hope the doctor the other processors listed above, we tear Scan cheaper for overseas fans is entirely reasonable.
Manga is to serve readers that
Either way, if a fan
Copyright by the manga here
Although they have read both and then buy that
Such as me.

Um
if so will have two solutions.

first: bite story that spends money to buy the publisher, bought just finished tearing out of view then fold paper airplanes, just cursed out so many people for this legislation.

second: to the same objection.

and I certainly will follow the second.
end.

no, that is causing the WSJ but ....

without KHR and OP is going to die fast

read OP of Kim Dong too inhibition

KHR is pirated copies ... but then they must also stop
end.

Shonen Jump's letter mainly affects the amount of raw uploader in Japan so Japan would certainly reduce the story (in case some uploader was arrested Tuesday as an example) so the other way is simpler and scan up to the network from the region that copyright law is low (such as Vietnam have) just moved out of date, the series can comfortably go online scan which I fear anyone, especially with the transfer of goods on This extremely easy story may be out today in the latest update will be about a week after that is the raw (or slower). As such, the story can only be to the fans in full rather than waiting until later raw manga was going to come right away, also in Vietnam at the copyright laws are respected, then at last it is disappearing at raw manga.

Actually, both latent luck this year and how much .... But what is also the face of it all. Say the prohibition scan, block raw will help up to the problem of revenue ahead of the manga-anime industry, but if you think in the long run will also have many other issues arise. For example, the no one can deny that the network community - those who scan, share raw illegally major contributors to the popularity of manga-anime beyond Japanese borders Ban.Chac sure that if there is no public the same network, no network worldwide otaku manga-anime is not popular as well as have a large fan community today. Moreover, many people have a habit of poll, or their own evaluation of a manga / anime that before deciding to give money to buy the collection, and to do so, the Internet serves as extreme critical period. In addition, revenue from that manga-anime publishers, manufacturers are not only earn income from Japanese fans but also a significant part in the foreign fans - those who truly love, ready spends money to ship the item with the original quality of those that I loved about the collection. So where did they get the resources than expected, while the barrier distribution rights in overseas manga-anime still many shortcomings and limitations? - Of course the answer is just a fan community that is the network - the Internet. Besides the fan usually will not because of some raw scans or earned on that principal refused to buy products if they have a chance. But if the block to source raw / scan, the chances of unauthorized known that many of you will return to zero, so hope to be anything else?

With most of the re-scan / raw in the whole network share is found, otaku for otaku, fans for fans, but also that no one dared to take the business profit. So the brutal truth that the law .... With almost all the raw scan can not be equal in quality to those original conditions, will also have the opportunity to put money into the original purchase only. In summary says this problem is two say it is also true to say that their support is, they interact each other again as no wrong. ~ ~

Haizz .... just try to go, then they will see. This momentum will keep a close on its own with the Japanese world, they will only read manga, watch anime on their own alone. Fact that the Japanese market is very large so perhaps this problem is also acceptable to many there, but can not deny that if it was true then they have lost many things, many sources interests, much like a good bargain at all.

Having said this, then say so but I still do not believe they banned anything but dull little game of this long ago but also thoroughly go anywhere where we do this as well as a few other social evils so that only , only the mouth but also to eliminate the root is where the Internet is now expanding into a great power which human can't defeat.

Oh ho, sending letter, email? Like I said, I was make a 2pic to criticism them, and it got some people agree, but the manga still not good enough.

And if the publishing houses want more license, why they don't make the deal with scanlators?

Don't you see the scanlators always keep the mangaka name, it still help people know who draw it, right?

And if they just wanna have the license, they should kept the manga, anime for their country, don't bring it to the other countries, license, haa, the real thing they want is lots of money, they were make the M-A like the tools to gets money for them.

If that a business, so they can sell the manga in their country, this still got money for them, and don't bring it to us, or at least to me, with me money like shit, because when you die, it not gonna help you.

And about mangaka, if they draw for money, why they don't draw the money and use it?

Manga was create to people read, and if people don't know the manga good or bad, how could they bought them?

About scans and trans, there one thing special: English is not the best language to trans, because a big part of English words have just one meaning, while Asia language got many meaning for one words, so when we trans, we like trans from JP to VN more than from EN to VN or the other language with other coutries, because it kept more true meaning than EN.

And with the rights to distribute, i said they should made the deal about scan time, why the Janpanese don't legalized it, why they like make it so hard? Do they wanna make a scandal to PR themself?

Because what's on the net, stays on the net.

Libraries, checking the content in bookstores, manga rentals (if you've got them), reviews, friends...

Oh, so what? People don't want buy manga, hah? Lots of people want save manga comic, not manga onl, because at least it still stronger than internet and PC - these things not always okay, they could damage anytime.

The entertaiment - like we call, it help us relax, and human made it like the industry, hohoho, to get money - thing that our ancestors don't need to survive, and they're not discharged thing we call industrial waste for their children too, right?

About mangaka, are things they draw exist in real world? If not, why they want transform the virtual things to the real money for themself, that so ridiculous.

So you think where these things have manga? It not falling from the sky, and in libraries, is it always have manga? And why you don't see that the internet was help a lots for manga and anime came to people nowadays? If you think scan raw manga is wrong, so you and these bastard publishers master should confiscation all scanners, printers in all wide world to keep the raw manga save, and requirements the mangaka and their assistants draw the hundred thousands page for one chapter to sell, and then close every single one site about manga, anime too, include this site, it help a lots for the business.

weren't you complaining about money a little while ago?

Yes, entertainment is a nice way to relax, but that doesn't mean it should be free.

MANGA IS NOT A RIGHT, it is a privilege. I thought that really needed to be said. You seem to believe that you have a "right" to entertainment, but you don't.

Also, don't give us that "Vietnam is poor blah blah blah" crap.