Forum - View topic

3 questions about anime

I have 3 questions about anime that I have been pondering on for a while now. The first one is are all animation coming from Japan considered anime? Or is it just the ones that are exported overseas considered anime?

Number two, does the drawing style of animation indicate whether it is or it isn't anime? I mean, looking at how an animated show is drawn, I can more or less tell if it is anime or not. I'm pretty sure Disney's Cinderella isn't anime, and I am sure that School Rumble is based on the illustrations, even if I didn't know that Disney's Cinderella was made by Americans, and School Rumble was from Japan.

As a follow up to the previous question, most anime are hand drawn, and a lot of American made animation these days are computer generated, does the technique tell us whether or not it is anime?

Number three, do we consider "anime" coming from other countries anime? These days there are a lot of "anime" coming from the US, and I believe we have some in the Philippines too, but are they really anime?

...someone will eventually post that the word 'anime' is short for animation in Japanese, and say that everything animated is anime. In my opinion, this is logical only if [you live in Japan and] your primary language is Japanese. The usage of the word in any place other than Japan, or for those whose primary language is not Japanese, is to refer to animation originating in Japan [only].

... honestly, I say just establish your own meaning and go with it. If you ask ... you may come out more confused. Even if you think my post is reasonable and makes sense, you will probably see at least 10 other posts with vastly different opinions, in agreement or disagreement, that all make more sense to you than mine.

All animation from Japan is considered Anime for the most part. There are scant numbers of titles produced in Japan which are not actually Anime, but they're the exception, not the rule.

Steven, would you please give an example of such a title?

All animation from Japan is considered Anime for the most part. There are scant numbers of titles produced in Japan which are not actually Anime, but they're the exception, not the rule.

Quote:

All animation from Japan is considered Anime for the most part. There are scant numbers of titles produced in Japan which are not actually Anime, but they're the exception, not the rule.

Sorry if it seems like i'm hi-jacking this post but I just have one little question. I've heard about how Avatar the last airbender and Oban Star Racers aren't anime so my question is, what if a japanese person, in japan made an anime that looked just like Dexter's Lab, would it still be anime?

Is anime about the people who make it, or the country that makes it?

Quote:

All animation from Japan is considered Anime for the most part. There are scant numbers of titles produced in Japan which are not actually Anime, but they're the exception, not the rule.

Sorry if it seems like i'm hi-jacking this post but I just have one little question. I've heard about how Avatar the last airbender and Oban Star Racers aren't anime so my question is, what if a japanese person, in japan made an anime that looked just like Dexter's Lab, would it still be anime?

Is anime about the people who make it, or the country that makes it?

The word "anime" is really nothing more than a term used to by non-Japanese speaking countries to define animation coming from a specific geographic region (that, of course, being Japan). It says nothing about the quality of the animation, the content of the animation, the style of the animation, or the relevance of the animation, and simply describes where the animation came from, using a word from that region's own native language ("anime" being a shortening of "a-ni-me-shu-n," which is "animation" written in katakana).

I personally specify that if the show came from a Japanese production studio, with the individuals at the head of production (director, producer, writer, etc.) working for that studio at the time the show is produced, then it's anime. The term does not exclude on the basis of race; if an American or a European or a Korean person is working for a Japanese production house (say, Sunrise or Madhouse) and produces a show, then he or she had a hand in producing anime. And an exception is made for simple outsourcing jobs, like doing in-between animation and similar gruntwork. If an American studio outsources in-betweening to Japan, then the show is not anime because that job is still being done under the American studio's direction. On the other hand, if Japan outsources in-betweening to Korea, the show is still anime because that job is still being overseen by the Japanese production studio that outsourced the work.