Forum - View topic

Why are so many anime so committed to not making sense?

Right now, I'm watching Summertime Rendering with a group of people. We're in the final arc, where things have completely gone without the rails, and the events are basically a mad fever dream. While one could kinda-sorta piece together a metaphorical meaning for the happenings, the moment-to-moment actions are *deeply* in what is commonly referred to as "Anime bull____".

We've seen it many, many times before, especially in endings. What I'm wondering is, why? Why is it so common for anime/manga to be so deeply committed to making little to no logical sense?

//Not saying that STR is anywhere close to the most egregious in this regard, but it's certainly part of a trend.

Quote:

Western culture just cares more about making sense than Japanese culture.

I suspect this is true. Years ago, I remember Justin Sevakis commenting on how Japanese audiences seem to have a greater tolerance for not understanding or knowing what is going on right away. This was in reference to how sometimes a show would pluck an episode out of sequence and make it the first episode just to kind of shake things up (I believe Divergence Eve did this, for example). I'd say Western audiences prefer to be oriented right off the bat. Again, I'm generalizing but I think it's mostly true.