View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
|
DarkCntry
Joined: 20 May 2004
Posts: 61
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 3:38 am
|
|
|
kenshin77 wrote: | I live in one of those Big cities (LA) that have alot of anime shops, and plenty of fans who are anime fans. I could careless if TAN or Comcast or Animax comes out to broadcast Anime. Untill either of channels can get into Satellite providers I could careless if TAN goes "belly up". Call me selfish, but I have supported TAN, and have asked My satellite provider to get the Anime network, but there hasn't been any acton from ADV or my satellite provider. |
Sadly the directly responsible party is the satellite provider. Without their consent ADV, or any channel for that matter, will not show up on their listings.
I personally know that TAN has been talking with DirectTV and another satellite provider for a modified On Demand component that would lead into the linear broadcast channel, but that's up to the providers, not ADV/TAN.
What people are not seeing here is that ADV/TAN are not trying to corner the market, they want people to know that Comcast is possibly going to drop their channel on the basis of possibilities with Sony on Animax. Hell, even if Comcast does get Animax this means that Comcast still gets the final word on who and where it goes to, this is why so many people in certain areas are not getting TAN when they should be. I know of three areas right now that Comcast is providing TAN to a section of it while not providing it for a neighboring city on the same feed line.
TAN's been pushing to get a linear channel on all the major providers but only one has taken the opportunity to do it, Insight is currently the only one with the linear broadcast. TAN, however, has been steadily increasing their VOD spread to new markets lately, and trying to push more into Canadian providers.
ADV was one of the first and is now one of the largest distributors in N. America for anime, to overlook their impact on this community would be, for lack of better words, stupid. No, they don't always do the best work or get the best shows, but I cannot find one licensing company out there that has done 100% flawless. ADV is still staffed by mainly anime fans from the vast employees that I've spoken to and while they will admit they are a business out to make money, they are also doing it with the best interests of the fans in mind.
Hell, as a Rep and Field Op for TAN I get a free DVD a month from them...along with at least 50 other people. Now doing simple math adding in the prices of these DVDs and multiplying by 50, this is quite a bit of money they are just letting go for the fans. All I am tasked to do is to spread the word about TAN and to do QA work for the schedules, which brings me to another issue with Comcast.
If anyone over the last month has had Comcast in the Jacksonville Florida area and saw the VOD schedule for TAN, they would know how royally screwed up they made the lineup. Would you guys believe that RahXephon and Evangelion are both comedies? And that Goldenboy was a drama? They had the whole lineup screwed up beyond belief and this lasted for almost a full month...if this is what Comcast plans on doing with their own channel, then I'm rather worried.
I have no qualms with Select on Demand (which again, I need to apparently point out, is not a direct relation to Comcast, it's an outsourced company providing VOD programming on various things), it's just that CPM's library is far from what TAN's is. And with TAN obviously picking up other licensed shows to televise, I'm sure I don't think I'd have to worry about running out of content on TAN where-as a CPM-based channel would seriously have some issues with me staying interested in.
I would love if my Comcast provided the linear channel for TAN, hell, I've done almost all I've can personally to push for it...but as witnessed and stated previously, Comcast really isn't in it for the customers. I'd love to get TAN just because of what I don't get on my VOD feeds, like when TAN decided to show Chrono Crusade prior to the DVD releases. It's just nice little things like that that makes it appeal to me more and more, it's not that I'm blindly following ADV around listening to their every whim like it's some gospel truth. ADV did what I wanted, an all-anime network...they did it first and currently, did it the best, and for that I will fight to keep it around.
|
Back to top |
|
|
rkenshin21
Joined: 20 Aug 2004
Posts: 32
Location: N.C.
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 4:10 am
|
|
|
Haiseikoh 1973 wrote: | TAN needs to worry about getting their service onto OTHER systems than fight Comcast.
I'm still waiting for them to get their collective asses onto Time Warner. |
Hmmm They are on time warner ON DEMAND. ^_~.
|
Back to top |
|
|
Haiseikoh 1973
Joined: 24 Apr 2004
Posts: 1590
Location: Waiting for the Japanese 1000 Gunieas.
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 4:21 am
|
|
|
I think it's about time someone decided to make a completely independent Anime Channel that gathers various anime from all the labels (basiclly, the labels bid on time slots) and goes into sort of a format like how most stations go:
Early morning stuff (Obscure series/shows, maybe J-Pop Music Videos?)
"Kiddie Fare" in the morning
Teenager/Semi-Adult stuff from after Lunch to Afternoon
Semi-Adult Evenings
Paid Programming/Infomercials from either the companies/retailers from regular Broadcast Transmission End.
Mature Block on Weekend Nights
|
Back to top |
|
|
littlegreenwolf
Joined: 10 Aug 2002
Posts: 4796
Location: Seattle, WA
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 7:14 am
|
|
|
rkenshin21 wrote: | Hmmm They are on time warner ON DEMAND. ^_~. |
I think that's only in select cities, because I have time warner, and have phoned them a number of times, and they don't get it, or at least not in my area.
*stares at DarkCntry's post* Jacksonville has TAN? That's only 60 miles from me, I want TAN. Hi fellow Floridian.
|
Back to top |
|
|
Toboe
Joined: 14 Apr 2004
Posts: 138
Location: Rakuen
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 7:51 am
|
|
|
littlegreenwolf wrote: | What this has to do with it is that it proves ADV is not afraid to put out a boxset worth over 150$ for just a third of the price. Heck, they're throwing away money they can possibly make here. They're just doing something nice for the fans. This is not the only title they've done it with either, so it's not one case in a few. (look at the BGC 2040 boxset, and their new "Essential Anime Collection")
|
So your interpretation of a company re-releasing budget titles is a "gift to the fans". ADV had released all of these titles before in single-disc releases (with terrible episode counts for Nadesico) and on VHS. They waited until those weren't selling anymore and then they released them AGAIN in budget-priced collections. Now they're releasing those shows for a fourth time in their "essential anime" series. It's called "getting the most time" out of a franchise or "milking it until people finally stop buying it".
By your logic, the big cuddly lovable fan-oriented company 20th Century Fox delivered a "gift to its fans" when they re-priced Moulin Rouge at 9.99 (or any one of countless other films rereleased for less money by any major studio). Please take the rose-colored glasses off now. You are being INCREDIBLY naive. ADV had a huge hand in the building of the anime industry and they deserve credit for that. Just like Disney had a huge hand in the building of the animation industry. I don't then interpret everything Disney does as some benevolent gesture to its many fans done not in the interest of profit but in the interest of goodwill. I think most of you would call me an idiot for thinking that.
Here's the problem, people: those of us who are upset at this press release, those of us who won't support this, aren't mad because we "hate ADV". I have many of their titles, they do good work. But this press release is excessive in its pandering: it assumes that we as anime fans would ONLY want The Anime Network and wouldn't even want to even LOOK at what Comcast is offering, so please loyal fans UNITE for ADV and call comcast and tell them YOU DON'T WANT A CHOICE! You want ADV's product and THAT'S IT.
Could you see this same press release coming out about Bandai? "Bandai thinks they can just release any old anime and you'll eat it up! Call Bandai and tell them to stop releasing anime right now! UNITE!"
It makes me sad that they think anime fans are that shallow and foolish to just blindly follow them. Some of us hate being taken for granted. I saw through that press release like saran wrap. Unfortunately I think a lot of you think like Littlegreenwolf, who very clearly has blinders on and has no problem being lead around by the nose. You all can go on acting as ADV's "loyal army", I'll be over here making decisions in my own interest, thanks.
|
Back to top |
|
|
littlegreenwolf
Joined: 10 Aug 2002
Posts: 4796
Location: Seattle, WA
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 8:31 am
|
|
|
Toboe, my point was they didn't HAVE to release the boxset at that price, but they did. Yes they released all of the anime in single dvds before, but did they do what other companies usually do, and throw it all into a box and charge how much each dvd was worth? No. It wasn't just a "gift", they are making money from it. I never said they weren't. However ADV is also being considerate for the fans when they mark the price down to about a quarter of what the dvds are worth, and in a boxset. You're comparing this to something such as a rerelease of regular dvd movies being cheaper. Yeah, they do that in an attempt to sell more but this is a different market. Can you not realise this is an anime boxset? How much do these things go for? How much are they worth, and how much is ADV selling it for? You cannot deny that 50-80 bucks is a big deal for an anime fan to get a whole 26 episodes for when originally each individual dvd with about 3-4 episodes was 30 bucks. That "deal" is what I'm talking about.
You wanna know who else does "deals" for fans? TRSI. They have sales all the time for fans. Example, I got the KareKano boxset for 40 bucks. Yeah, they probably weren't selling a lot, so this probably led to the pricedrop/sale, but hey, I would of bought it for only around 90 bucks, and even at that price I still would of thought it a great deal.
My point is, these companies don't HAVE to have such drastic price drops to sell more of this. The price of the dvds is being cut down to about a quarter of what they originally sold for.
Toboe wrote: | I saw through that press release like saran wrap. Unfortunately I think a lot of you think like Littlegreenwolf, who very clearly has blinders on and has no problem being lead around by the nose. You all can go on acting as ADV's "loyal army", I'll be over here making decisions in my own interest, thanks. |
Really Toboe, if you have been reading my post as well as you think you have, you'll notice I made fun of this move by ADV in my very first post of this thread, and I AM making decisions based on my own intrest. I never said I was against Comcast releasing anime. I'm against them dropping TAN in favor of their own release of anime. They can compete all they want, but dropping a competitor for their own intrest I'm against. You need to get your head out of your derriere and quit being so cynical of another person’s opinion that you don’t seem to be capable of comprehending, and quit sprouting your notions of other people as fact.
|
Back to top |
|
|
the_soultaker
Joined: 25 Mar 2004
Posts: 685
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 8:59 am
|
|
|
I think your'e (Toboe)are either very passionate about this subject or just overreacting to the opposition from us "Loyal ADV fans".
In a perfect world it would be cool if we can have a channel that would broadcast Anime from various distro comps, but i for one have no faith whatsoever with Comca$h's business policies especially after witnessing the travesty that is G4Tech TV.
(I must admit that Nagisa was right when he forecasted how bad Tech TV will get post G4 accuisition.)
Any fool can tell you that ADV is in it for the money, so effing what? ANN staff are no doubt fans of Anime, but at the same time Tempest is not putting this site mainly out of a labor of love. people have bills to pay y'know, and there's nothing better than getting a check for doing something that you love.
TAN is used a vehicle to expand the Anime fanbase and of course encourage those to purchase their products (DVDs)
if the subscriber happens to enjoy one of the various on demand titles.It's a simple try-before-buy procedure, and for a low price of $6.95 a month,who's gonna really b**ch and moan?
Toboe,although i disagree with some of your posts, i respect your opinions which you are entitled to, but throwing cheapshots at other posters who happen to disagree, may undermine the messages you are getting across.
Oh and Tempest and EMerje; I'm a bit surprised that the Japanese TV stations would edit (selective) Anime series
for content.(this justifies, why i prefer OVAs over TV series anyday.) But i assume thier standards and practices are still more liberal than America's.Business wise It may be a good thing to release special editions with bonus unreleased scenes
due to censorship, but such content restrictions i feel,impede on the writer's/director's artistic expressions. As one may be aware of, this same trend is happening with Threatrical releases-to-DVDs (often known as the Director's cut) primary examples are the Chronicles of Riddick and Daredevil. (The latter would have recieved more praise from the moviegoers and Marvel fanbase, had this cut actually made it in the threaters. DD may be a good execption. but who want s to pay for a set of DVD Anime series that you may already have, but with new scenes that were previously editied for television?
(I.E. Robotech and NGE) That i would have a gripe with ADV for, but then again the same aforementioned re-releases are being aired on the affordable Anime Network.
And yes, Toboe and Juniper; ADV still kicks ass! after all, they have one of the best series out there MEZZO ONE. Sure comcast,bring it on we shall see who will be the "last man standing" On a side note, Gatsu and LGW have made some valid arguements to counter your posts. and with humor at that.
Last edited by the_soultaker on Wed Dec 08, 2004 2:43 pm; edited 1 time in total
|
Back to top |
|
|
Toboe
Joined: 14 Apr 2004
Posts: 138
Location: Rakuen
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 9:54 am
|
|
|
littlegreenwolf wrote: | Toboe, my point was they didn't HAVE to release the boxset at that price, but they did. Yes they released all of the anime in single dvds before, but did they do what other companies usually do, and throw it all into a box and charge how much each dvd was worth? No. It wasn't just a "gift", they are making money from it. I never said they weren't. However ADV is also being considerate for the fans when they mark the price down to about a quarter of what the dvds are worth, and in a boxset. You're comparing this to something such as a rerelease of regular dvd movies being cheaper. Yeah, they do that in an attempt to sell more but this is a different market. Can you not realise this is an anime boxset? How much do these things go for? How much are they worth, and how much is ADV selling it for? You cannot deny that 50-80 bucks is a big deal for an anime fan to get a whole 26 episodes for when originally each individual dvd with about 3-4 episodes was 30 bucks. That "deal" is what I'm talking about.
My point is, these companies don't HAVE to have such drastic price drops to sell more of this. The price of the dvds is being cut down to about a quarter of what they originally sold for.
Really Toboe, if you have been reading my post as well as you think you have, you'll notice I made fun of this move by ADV in my very first post of this thread, and I AM making decisions based on my own intrest. I never said I was against Comcast releasing anime. I'm against them dropping TAN in favor of their own release of anime. They can compete all they want, but dropping a competitor for their own intrest I'm against. You need to get your head out of your derriere and quit being so cynical of another person’s opinion that you don’t seem to be capable of comprehending, and quit sprouting your notions of other people as fact. |
So you honestly think that they are purposefully losing money on something "for the fans". You honestly interpret them marking something down - something very well past it's prime, something where the original (overpriced with low episode counts) DVDs weren't moving anymore - as some kind of benevolent gesture. The point is that the reason anyone marks anything down is to move more copies. Right Stuf is clearing out the warehouse, moving product that isn't moving well anymore. Thinking that this is some kind of Gift From Above, from these wonderful teddybear companies that just love you so much, is foolish and naive. I can't interpret it as anything else and I'm sorry if you're offended by that but it's true. Learn a little about economics and how to run a business and then come back and tell me you feel the same way.
Also, to wit, aren't you the one who complained a whole lot about ADV releasing Loki Ragnarok and Peacemaker manga that was halfway through the series' run? So what was that then, some benevolent decision made to please the fans, or a cash grab tie-in that was convenient for them? They released Peacemaker Kurogane to go along with the anime series, even though the manga made little to no sense at all if you hadn't read the first, what, seven volumes that they didn't have the rights to? Yeah, ADV makes decisions all the time 'for the good of the fans', don't they? This was a deliberate release designed to sell more copies of a manga title they KNEW was extremely questionable, something that wouldn't make a heck of a lot of sense to most people, but they did it anyway just because they knew the manga would sell better now if they tied it in to the anime. Go ahead and defend that decision using the same logic you're using to defend this.
As for spouting my 'notions of other people as fact' (what the heck does that even mean?), my head has been firmly planted in my own derriere for many moons now (get it, moons?!) and I still make more sense than you do.
|
Back to top |
|
|
Juniper
Joined: 07 Dec 2004
Posts: 51
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 11:04 am
|
|
|
the_soultaker wrote: | And yes, Toboe and Juniper; ADV still ass! after all, they have one of the best series out there MEZZO ONE. Sure comcast,bring it on we shall see who will be the "last man standing" On a side note, Gatsu and LGW have made some valid points/arguements to counter your posts and with humor at that. |
WOAH. ADV has a title you like! They rawk!!!!
I don't hate ADV. I don't even dislike ADV. ADV titles populate much of my anime library. Everyone keeps going back to the same thing over and over and over again, and it's the silly thought that Comcast is going to be running it's own anime channel.
No.
Comcast, if they do get an anime channel, is going to acquire someone else's network and air it. This big shadowy organization full of so many suits that you all love to hate... is going to aquire someone else's network... a network run by people who know their stuff. The thing is, none of this has even happened yet. Getting your panties in a bundle over something that hasn't even happened yet is a waste of energy and hell on your panties.
Comcast is a content provider. They provide content. TAN is not making them money. Another business venture might make them more. Okay. Deal with it. It's called a "business decision." Maybe it'll work in their favor, maybe it won't. But that's their business decision, so that they make more money, because that's what companies do. Watching someone take away your chance to watch an anime channel... eh. Comcast bringeth, Comcast taketh away. Deal with it.
|
Back to top |
|
|
the_soultaker
Joined: 25 Mar 2004
Posts: 685
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 12:07 pm
|
|
|
[quote="Juniper"]
the_soultaker wrote: | And yes, Toboe and Juniper; ADV still ass! after all, they have one of the best series out there MEZZO ONE. Sure comcast,bring it on we shall see who will be the "last man standing" On a side note, Gatsu and LGW have made some valid points/arguements to counter your posts and with humor at that. |
Juniper wrote: | [WOAH. ADV has a title you like! They rawk!!!! |
Yes they do, and i like more than one title in their expanding catalog.
Quote: | Comcast, if they do get an anime channel, is going to acquire someone else's network and air it. This big shadowy organization full of so many suits that you all love to hate... is going to aquire someone else's network... a network run by people who know their stuff. The thing is, none of this has even happened yet. Getting your panties in a bundle over something that hasn't even happened yet is a waste of energy and hell on your panties. |
"Panties"? it's boxer briefs goddammit!
Quote: | Comcast is a content provider. They provide content. TAN is not making them money. Another business venture might make them more. Okay. Deal with it. It's called a "business decision." Maybe it'll work in their favor, maybe it won't. But that's their business decision, so that they make more money, because that's what companies do. Watching someone take away your chance to watch an anime channel... eh. Comcast bringeth, Comcast taketh away. Deal with it. |
There's simply nothing to deal with, should Comca$h provide another alternative, i still doubt they will succeed to engulf TAN's market share. especially when looking at their track record. *scoffs* I for the most part rent and purchase DVDs and yes i'm a TAN subscriber (my provider is Cablevision)
So hey either way Comcast' plans have no effect on me whatsoever. ADV should concentrate on acquiring other cable markets like time warner and adjust their format as Haiseikoh 1973 mentioned. this would atleast give them a headstart/advantage over this other Anime Channel. ADV has the resources,titles,etc. thus they should utilize them to the fullest. let's wait and see shall we?
Last edited by the_soultaker on Wed Dec 08, 2004 3:23 pm; edited 1 time in total
|
Back to top |
|
|
herbkir
Joined: 17 Jun 2003
Posts: 251
Location: Michigan
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 12:16 pm
|
|
|
First, as a satellite viewer I'm not getting TAN, and so far none of its would-be competitors have said anything about an interest in satellite viewers.
Our local Comcast cable system is an old 120-channel dinosaur that doesn't have VOD capability. With limited room, the niche services offered cater to local interests, which don't include anime. (People here in central Mich. think anime means Pokemon or porn, if they've even heard of it. Most haven't.)
It would be great if TAN were available on Dish Network and DirectTV. That would be a competitive alternative to whatever anime channel Comcast chose to run. Then your choice would be losing local channels to gain an anime network. To the ADV bashers out there, remember that ADV became a successful company by finding out what its customers wanted and then doing its best to deliver exactly that.
Also, despite a phenomenal growth rate, anime is still a tiny niche in a vast entertainment market. Adult Swim, the most widely available adult-level TV anime source in the nation, averages just over 500,000 viewers nightly. Cartoon Network's kiddie anime block in the afternoons averages about 1.2 million viewers. These are profitable for CN, but in the larger entertainment universe these numbers are minuscule. It's still an open question of whether this market will support one anime network, let alone 2 or 3. (^_*)
|
Back to top |
|
|
HeeroTX
Joined: 15 Jul 2002
Posts: 2046
Location: Austin, TX
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 12:50 pm
|
|
|
GATSU wrote: |
Quote: | ADV came along at an opportune time and made some wise business choices that allowed them to be as they are now. But under no circumstances can anyone ever say that ADV is to thank for the American anime industry. That's just ignorance. |
Yes. Those Rumiko Takahashi tv shows from Viz and Animeigo were the reason the industry is a success story. Forget about Devil Hunter Yohko, Blue Seed, and Evangelion.
|
OK, that's just ignorant. Yohko built ADV and was an important title in THEIR library, but honestly enjoyed no more success than any other "niche" title of it's day. And Blue Seed?!? Blue Seed?!? Comparatively speaking, Blue Seed went nowhere. Evangelion was "the title" for ADV for whatever reason. (it "spoke" to this generation, people ascribed meaning to it, whatever) But to say Eva MADE this industry or MADE things work is LUDICROUS.
This current boom is due to 3, maybe 4 things. They are, in order:
-Pokemon
-Sailor Moon
-Dragonball Z
-Ghost in the Shell/Spirited Away (MAYBE)
The first, had an obvious impact and really "made" the whole anime marketting structure we currently "enjoy". (and yes, when your local comic store starts carrying anime toys because Pokemon blew open the doors for weird anime merchandise, you can thank the ridiculously marketable fighting animals)
Sailor Moon brought in the girls. That's sexist, it's a generalization, but it's true. Sailor Moon showed that girls would buy just as much foreign crap as nerd guys. You can thank Sailor Moon for shoujo manga and anime in ANY form. (you can also thank Sailor Moon for adding the female sex to anime cons in any ratio greater than 85/15 (m/f))
DBZ built anime on Cartoon Network, period. Cartoon Network BUILT the concept of a station dedicated to only animation. To pretend otherwise is to be naive. Shows like PPG built the network, but without DBZ, you'd probably never have FMA (on tv).
And GitS and Spirited Away got "mainstream" attention for "non-kiddie" anime. *shrug*
Evangelion was to ADV what Ranma was to Viz (maybe more so, but still..) a successful title that sold many tapes/LDs/DVDs, but never really broke out of the "niche". It made a lot of money for ADV, but realistically, it didn't really "make" the market. The market for an Eva was already there. The above 3 (maybe 4) BUILT a new market.
All that said, ADV is run by some good people, whether or not you personally agree with their decisions or like those people, they are fans and have given to the fan community sometimes.
-At a con almost 10 years ago, the power died for like half a day or more, ADV pulled a van into the parking lot, hooked up a TV to the car battery and showed anime out the back of the van for hours. Clever marketting ploy? or nice show of assistance for the fans and the con? Up to you. (I dunno what they showed, so don't ask, I'd assume it was ADV titles, but I dunno)
-At cons about 5 yrs ago ADV used to give out Freebie "parking permits" based on organizations in shows they sold (NERV, WWWA, etc). This was totally free when they could've been sold as merchandise. It was marketting, but it was nice. And when I asked them directly (via email) for one for a friend after they'd stopped giving them away at cons, they sent me several.
I think any recent issues regarding ADV and fans is simply a result of size. I DO think ADV is less responsive to and maybe less in tune with anime fans, but I think the same is probably true of say Anime Expo. Size brings distance.
Mark Cuban is a basketball fan, but that doesn't mean he's not going to make decisions for the Dallas Mavericks based on what he thinks is best for the organization. ADV is the same way. With GOOD fans, it works out for the best for both, the owner makes a property that he/she AS A FAN likes, and you as a fan get to also enjoy the property. For contrast:
-I think AnimEigo is run by a FAN, and I think said fan picked titles that he likes, market be d@mned. AnimEigo hasn't grown like ADV because what *I* like is probably different from what YOU like. Farscape might have been quality TV, but Springer gets the viewers, ya know? Urusei Yatsura was a great show in its day, but that ship has sailed, and its not one for wide market appeal in the US right now.
-Spirited Away was a great movie, I'd recommend it to anyone and it won an Oscar. Disney/Buena Vista didn't give much of a rat's @ss about it and it's theater run suffered, DVD sales suffered (I mean, it sold, but it didn't get the push it could have) and was just generally somewhat disappointing.
If you're TOO much of a fan, your company is only gonna make it on luck. (if you're a fan of just the right thing)
If you're NOT a fan, the product will suffer.
ADV is shooting for a balance, I think they do alright. They may not be the "ideal", but hey, it's not a perfect world.
(and wow, sorry that got so long)
|
Back to top |
|
|
littlegreenwolf
Joined: 10 Aug 2002
Posts: 4796
Location: Seattle, WA
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 1:41 pm
|
|
|
Toboe wrote: | So you honestly think that they are purposefully losing money on something "for the fans". You honestly interpret them marking something down - something very well past it's prime, something where the original (overpriced with low episode counts) DVDs weren't moving anymore - as some kind of benevolent gesture. The point is that the reason anyone marks anything down is to move more copies. Right Stuf is clearing out the warehouse, moving product that isn't moving well anymore. Thinking that this is some kind of Gift From Above, from these wonderful teddybear companies that just love you so much, is foolish and naive. I can't interpret it as anything else and I'm sorry if you're offended by that but it's true. Learn a little about economics and how to run a business and then come back and tell me you feel the same way.. |
Not purposely "loosing" money. Purposely passing up making less money than they could. And Toboe, screw you. I am well aware of how economics works, and sometimes companies DO sacrifice goods to attract more potential cusomters. Don't start preaching to me about learning what economics is when I just finished that class *which btw was an honors class* in which I had to write a whole freaking essay on Ben and Jerry's; the beginning to present. You know what B&J do? They have free icecream days. Odalalee, now why would they do that? It's certianly not to clear out their current icecream stock because they buy extra just for this day. Now why do they do this? To get on the customer's good side, and to create a loyal fanbase. Businesses all over do it, and you fellow forum grumbler, really need to go back to economics if you've never heard of it before.
Toboe wrote: | Also, to wit, aren't you the one who complained a whole lot about ADV releasing Loki Ragnarok and Peacemaker manga that was halfway through the series' run? So what was that then, some benevolent decision made to please the fans, or a cash grab tie-in that was convenient for them? They released Peacemaker Kurogane to go along with the anime series, even though the manga made little to no sense at all if you hadn't read the first, what, seven volumes that they didn't have the rights to? Yeah, ADV makes decisions all the time 'for the good of the fans', don't they? This was a deliberate release designed to sell more copies of a manga title they KNEW was extremely questionable, something that wouldn't make a heck of a lot of sense to most people, but they did it anyway just because they knew the manga would sell better now if they tied it in to the anime. Go ahead and defend that decision using the same logic you're using to defend this.. |
Ha, you're bringing up Loki. I love Loki. That's my favourite subject. Well, you asked for it.
ADV did screw up all those titles they licensed in bulk. However, I as a fan of a number of those titles, especially Loki, actually forgive them. Why? Because they're new to the manga scene.
It also seems to me that MagGarden just offered ADV a big deal of licensing a load of manga titles to help them get started. MagGarden however has a number of sequal titles that they don't own the original series to. Did they let ADV know about this or not? No idea, and I don't care. ADV licnesed the 2nd Loki series. Not the first. They got it in a big bulk deal they got with other titles. The way I see it is they could of waited until they licensed the first series, and THEN released it, or they could of just went ahead and started releasing it. Now if they waited to license the first series, I'd probably be waiting a very long time to get any Loki in English. This would of made me a very sad fan. I'm happier to get some of the Loki series instead of none, because for all I know the first series will never come out here. They COULD go way out of their way and hunt down the rights to the first series, but there's no gaurentee that the series is worth it for them. So I forgive them, and understand they're having problems.
Also, another reason why I'm not a fan yelling for blood is that they have licensed the anime, and the ADV represenative at a con said they ARE indeed looking into licensing the first manga series. They could mainly be having problems because the original publisher which was a branch of Enix, sort of went out of business about five years ago. The company as merged recently, and well, for all I know they have problems looking up these rights if ADV inquires.
Anyway, I think ADV's release of the 2nd series of the Loki is in fact a good move for the "fans". Like I said earlier, ADV could of just sat on the property for years and waited, or they could of went ahead and released the series. I'm a Loki fan. I wanted the 2nd series. I got the 2nd series, and I am a very happy Loki fan. It's the people who are not originally Loki fans picking up this manga, looking at it, and having no idea of what's going on that are suffering. But I'm a greedy fan, and don't really care so much for those. I have a site they can go look up info if they get confused enough on it.
Toboe wrote: | As for spouting my 'notions of other people as fact' (what the heck does that even mean?), my head has been firmly planted in my own derriere for many moons now (get it, moons?!) and I still make more sense than you do. |
A 'notion' is an opinion. Does it make more sense when I say "sprouting opinions of other people as fact"? I really do hope you understand the sentence now. You know, there is a book called a dictionary used in cases just like these when you come across words you don't understand.
|
Back to top |
|
|
Toboe
Joined: 14 Apr 2004
Posts: 138
Location: Rakuen
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 2:12 pm
|
|
|
littlegreenwolf wrote: | Not purposely "loosing" money. Purposely passing up making less money than they could. And Toboe, screw you. I am well aware of how economics works, and sometimes companies DO sacrifice goods to attract more potential cusomters. Don't start preaching to me about learning what economics is when I just finished that class *which btw was an honors class* in which I had to write a whole freaking essay on Ben and Jerry's; the beginning to present. You know what B&J do? They have free icecream days. Odalalee, now why would they do that? It's certianly not to clear out their current icecream stock because they buy extra just for this day. Now why do they do this? To get on the customer's good side, and to create a loyal fanbase. Businesses all over do it, and you fellow forum grumbler, really need to go back to economics if you've never heard of it before.
A 'notion' is an opinion. Does it make more sense when I say "sprouting opinions of other people as fact"? I really do hope you understand the sentence now. You know, there is a book called a dictionary used in cases just like these when you come across words you don't understand. |
Oh excuse me, an HONORS class! Well well! I took HONORS Economics a million years ago when I was in high school, does that make me an expert? Uh, no!
Anyway your allegory doesn't work. If Ben & Jerry's has a flavor they've had around forever and suddenly stops selling, and they discount it, THAT is a valid allegory to what happened with Nadesico. You aren't even arguing the same situation, you're coming up with something totally tangental because you're thinking about it WRONG. ADV releasing a budget comp of Nadesico IS NOT GENEROSITY. Unfortunately you live under this absolutely crazy notion and no amount of sense talking will get you to see reason so forget it. Next time I have some stale bread and mark it down to 99 cents, feel free to laud me as a Saint for being so generous and kind to you.
As for the Loki thing you're operating on a double standard. I guarantee you ADV knew what they were buying. Nobody's that ignorant about what they're paying millions of dollars for. They knew what they had, they knew what it was worth, they knew how they could sell it. But people like you will forgive just about anything, eh, because the company was started by fans. Whatever.
And I questioned the meaning of your sentence because your grammar is so absolutely atrocious that I could barely make sense of what you were trying to say. Read your stuff aloud to yourself next time before posting it and see if it flows or sounds right; most of your writing is awkward like a high schooler at a frat party. Hell, read what you just wrote. "Sprouting" opinions. Classic.
Anyway I think we've torn eachothers' throats out enough over this, we'll agree to disagree.
|
Back to top |
|
|
HeeroTX
Joined: 15 Jul 2002
Posts: 2046
Location: Austin, TX
|
Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2004 2:59 pm
|
|
|
HeeroTX wrote: |
OK, that's just ignorant. |
Uh, I just want to say that this was said for effect and not meant to read as inflammatory as it no doubt does. That said, I think the importance of the titles you noted (Yohko & Blue Seed for certain, Eva, probably just IMO) is lower than you seem to be implying.
|
Back to top |
|
|
|