Forum - View topic

Trends in hyperviolence in anime.

There's a certain movie that's been released multiple times before in the U.S. market but will finally be making its way to Blu-Ray next month. And the last time we reviewed it, the reviewer commented extensively about how the title didn't really fit the time in which it was being released. I was planning to angle my upcoming review of it based on how this discussion plays out.

Of course, not all shows with an 'intense' objectionable rating have extreme violence. So going through the titles and judging by ANN reviews and google here's a list of titles with hyperviolence per year (list includes series, movies and OVAs):

So stuff like Shiki wouldn't be considered hyper-violent then, because barring spoiler[the dissection scene] all the violence is in the final quarter? I'm not arguing here, just want to know what you think.

I was thinking of doing something similar to the list you made, but instead ask people to submit shows that they felt fit the category of ultra, hyper, or extreme violence. Then we could discuss them, because like you pointed out not everything that is listed as "intense" is consistently hyperviolent throughout a show. Birdy the Mighty: Decode 2 is listed as "intense" but I don't see it in the same category as Elfen Lied. A more detailed list might also reveal some other elements..... Anybody interested in doing this or any changes or additions?

We might find it difficult to differentiate from hyperviolent shows and shows that have a couple hyperviolent scenes but otherwise are tame though.

True, but I think that's where the experience of ANN members comes in to help us get a clearer picture. Also as Key stated we are looking at a range here with something like Claymore being representative of the low end and maybe Elfen Lied leaning towards the high end. I think one scene of extreme violence doesn't fit the criteria of consistent violence, but maybe 3 or 4 do. Every episode doesn't have to be chock full of violence for it to be consistent or purposeful. What do you think?

So stuff like Shiki wouldn't be considered hyper-violent then, because barring spoiler[the dissection scene] all the violence is in the final quarter? I'm not arguing here, just want to know what you think.

I was just contemplating this. I lean towards yes, it is hyperviolent, but as soon as you compare to Deadman Wonderland or many of these others, it looks positively mild.

Adding to the list: Shigurui: Death Frenzy (2007), Umineko: When They Cry (2009), The Animatrix (2003), Ayakashi (2007), Afro Samurai (2007), When They Cry: Higurashi (2006), and RIN - Daughters of Mnemosyne (2006).

It's been awhile since I've seen Murder Princess and can't remember if it's bloody enough to qualify here. I remember there's a lot of blood and killing, but can't remember if it reaches hyperviolent levels.

Also, why do you have the Hellsing volumes listed individually?

many violent things about Shiki... Mild compared to the really hyperviolent titles, true, but if Claymore is the base then I would put Shiki about the same. The only difference is that Claymore spread its violence out whereas Shiki saved most of its violence for a select few episodes.

I've got RIN as being 2008 here

As far as Corpse Princess I will add an * to denote that it is up for debate or discussion. I can't remember myself, but someone else posted it.

Because those were the years that the volumes were released in Japan. They are basically individual movies roughly about 50 minutes in length each. The last Hellsing vol 10 will be released in Japan this December.

One-Eye wrote:

As far as Corpse Princess I will add an * to denote that it is up for debate or discussion. I can't remember myself, but someone else posted it.

Do you mean Murder Princess, the title I was referring to, or Corpse Princess?

I wouldn't describe The Animatrix as hyperviolent. Only Second Renaissance Part 2 would have moments that warrant that but, even then, it's not gross or disturbing.

Did you mean Ayakashi 2007 or Ayakashi: Samurai Horror tales which I think was 2006. I've seen parts of both but can't remember about the violence content.