Forum - View topic

Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex (TV + OAV + movies).

Oh, and before I forget. The "Official Log" DVD, that's just a compilation of the Laughing Man case, right? Is it just recyled animation with new narration, or is it completely original?

For as big as a fan you are (or at least seem) it's definitely worth the money

But that was a fun episode to see The Major, Togusa, and Batou scare those little punks spoiler[ and the lead one pissed his pants ]. The concept of spoiler[ organ cloning seems like it'd be something very possible in our society, though the whole idea of cybernetic prosthetics seems way behind in comparison at this point.]

Thinking about it now, the way they depict technology in this series reminds me a lot of Star Trek: The Next Generation; it's all plausible in theory, but more than likely way ahead of our time. However, it's the great mark of a visionary that sure provides a lot of hope, I suppose.

And as for the voices, I actually liked most of the dub (besides the aforementioned Tachikomas, who were still funny in Tachikoma Days). The voices of Togusa, Aramaki, Batou and the Major all sounded natural, with the rest being not far behind.

Her delivery was natural (monotone yes, but it was consistent monotone ), and it suited her character design.

But I liked Togusa's VA the best. Didn't really sound like a policeman (not spoiler tagging that, it was never a secret). But still, he sounded like a guy you would meet in the street, I never thought any of his lines sounded strange or wrong. I need to check up on what other roles the VA has done, because I suspect he merely used his natural voice, which is totally fine here.

As for only watching the first two DVDs, it will pay to watch the rest of the series (if you liked what you have seen so far). It gets way better later on, but the last episode spoiler[is rather quiet, lots of talk, things get wrapped up. But it is the few episodes before the end which really are the best, with heaps of action. For all the philosophy, GitS is at its best when the action is in the "on" position.]

Just finished episodes 11 & 12.

In 11, spoiler[ is there something more to that Aoi guy later in the series. Judging from his communiaction setup in that panel and the Laughing Man motto written on the cover, and not to mention his ability in wiping everyone's memory in that entire facility, his cyber skills seem like they'd be a real threat, or at least very useful later on. A simple yes or no will suffice, no need for details.

Also, is he just a fan of the Laughing Man and was he really suffering from post-whatever syndrome like everyone else? Well, I doubt that second part since he was referred to as "cheif" and probably put on that vegetable personality of his to throw everyone off (great allusion to the catcher's mitt).]

And 12 was especially fun. spoiler[ Tachikoma gets a chance to shine, we also get that heart-warming anecdote about the goldfish, and then the social commentary by way of that old man's cyberbrain movie theater.

That scene in particular does a great job illustrating how people can get stuck in a sort of "dream world." But at some point, we all just have to wake up. It sort of reminds me of the concept behind The Matrix, though without the whole "robots rule the world, and our bodies are their food" theme.

Personally, I'm closer to being a realist like The Major, though probably not as concise about it. I mean, I do watch anime after all, where "realism" is a rarity in itself. But I really like that aspect about her (as well as other characters that to tend to show that kind of personality in other titles).]

This series does an excellent job of mixing all sorts of themes and characters. You've got action, drama, and mystery in all of the "police" episodes, and now they even manage a fun, little brain-teaser with some very subtle comedy in it; definitely worth any anime fan's time.

To your episode 11 question a yes or no doesn't work unfortunately, it is a completely subjective view in that instance. I would say no personally but I know people will disagree with that for there own reasons. When you finish the series ask that question again if you are still curious. I should clarify, I was reffering to your question of whether he is a threat or not. But yes, there is more to him.

This series only gets better I have seen SAC 4 times and the 2nd gig 3 times.

This is without a doubt the best show I have ever seen, it is incredible how deep it is and how well it is made. Not to mention the music, best music in any anime. God I love this show...