Forum

I've noticed that someone entered a bunch of wrong information for the Shin Gakuen Tengoku manga because they confused it with a different Tengoku manga. Shin Gakuen Tengoku ran in Margaret, but the other Tengoku manga ran in Ultra Jump. I reported the image and one of the alternate titles as erroneous, but all of the listed genres and themes are also sourced using the same source that is about the wrong manga. I was thinking it would be easier to have someone just remove all of the information from the wrong source rather than audit each of the genres and themes individually. Or perhaps someone could create a new entry for the Tengoku manga from Ultra Jump since I don't think it has its own entry in the encyclopedia yet.

I saw that a new encyclopedia entry was created today for Tengoku - Heaven's Prison, and that the image and alternate title that had erroneously been added to the Shin Gakuen Tengoku entry have been moved to the Tengoku - Heaven's Prison entry. However, all the genres and themes listed in the Shin Gakuen Tengoku entry should also be moved to the Tengoku - Heaven's Prison entry. If you check the sources for those genres and themes, you will see that they were also added by the same person who added the other Heaven's Prison info to Shin Gakuen Tengoku. I had previously reported them as erroneous with the audit system, but since they are probably correct genres and themes for Tengoku - Heaven's Prison, it would probably make more sense to move them there rather than just remove them.

Also, thanks for taking care of this issue.

Calathan wrote:

I saw that a new encyclopedia entry was created today for Tengoku - Heaven's Prison, and that the image and alternate title that had erroneously been added to the Shin Gakuen Tengoku entry have been moved to the Tengoku - Heaven's Prison entry. However, all the genres and themes listed in the Shin Gakuen Tengoku entry should also be moved to the Tengoku - Heaven's Prison entry. If you check the sources for those genres and themes, you will see that they were also added by the same person who added the other Heaven's Prison info to Shin Gakuen Tengoku. I had previously reported them as erroneous with the audit system, but since they are probably correct genres and themes for Tengoku - Heaven's Prison, it would probably make more sense to move them there rather than just remove them.

For genre submissions there's actually no such thing as "moving" them from one title to another; they are just marked with a "false" tag and, if really necessary, re-submitted to another title with proper credits. In this case I don't see it's necessary to give credits to someone who couldn't tell the difference between Rinko Ueda and Hiroyuki Utatane so it's fine for you to add genre for Tengoku - Heaven's Prison.

To avoid further confusion I've added the cover of Shin Gakuen Tengoku volume 1. Not the best picture but better than nothing.

Calathan wrote:

Also, thanks for taking care of this issue.

No problem. Thanks for reporting and sorry for taking so long to have them fixed.

Well, I haven't actually read Heaven's Prison, so I don't want to add the themes and genres to it myself. I think they would probably be correct for that manga, but don't want to commit to it without reading it. But thanks for removing them from Shin Gauken Tenkogu.