Forum - View topic

NEWS: To Your Eternity Manga Ends 2nd Arc, 3rd Arc Begins on January 25

Well, I honestly do not understand what exact reason makes WSM still even trying to keep To Your Eternity - it's like watching people still trying to sail on a ship that is eaten by rust so much that is already broken in pieces.

The second arc cemented TYE as the automatic bottom tier of WSM ToC ratings no matter how they push it, like getting CP for one volume to getting straight back to the last place on the next. The manga volume sales diminished to the point that the latest volumes barely can sell 20k, and that is after the anime series release. The upcoming second season will not help it either.

Really, at this point keeping this trainwreck sounds like a joke about the editors of WSM being so out of touch that they will axe absolutely everything, but TYE will still live.

WANNFH wrote:

Well, I honestly do not understand what exact reason makes WSM still even trying to keep To Your Eternity - it's like watching people still trying to sail on a ship that is eaten by rust so much that is already broken in pieces. The second arc cemented TYE as the automatic bottom tier of WSM ToC ratings no matter how they push it, like getting CP for one volume to getting straight back to the last place on the next. The manga volume sales diminished to the point that the latest volumes barely can sell 20k, and that is after the anime series release. The upcoming second season will not help it either. Really, at this point keeping this trainwreck sounds like a joke about the editors of WSM being so out of touch that they will axe absolutely everything, but TYE will still live.

Well, I loved the first season of the anime, and hope their will be more manga and anime seasons to come. Even if TYE goes of the rails, people still wanted Promised Neverland to continue, and after some point, that just devolved into some weird bullshit in which all the characters agreed genocide was logical, and only one of them opposed genocide for emotional reasons (FFS, genocide is not logical). I doubt this "goes off the rails" anywhere near the degree TPN did. Call me whatever, but I prefer something like To Your Eternity, which has potential to be a masterpeice, than the most polished story with no potential to be a masterpeice, I don't rate based on how few plotholes or how on-model the animation is, I rate based on how it makes me feel.

I'm currently finishing up the first season since for some reason I never watched it despite loving the first episode. The prison island arc is definitely worse and the animation definitely took a hit but I still wouldn't say it's AWFUL yet like I remember so many people saying. The worst probably has yet to come but at least this part is good.

Well, I loved the first season of the anime, and hope their will be more manga and anime seasons to come. Even if TYE goes of the rails, people still wanted Promised Neverland to continue, and after some point, that just devolved into some weird bullshit in which all the characters agreed genocide was logical, and only one of them opposed genocide for emotional reasons (FFS, genocide is not logical). I doubt this "goes off the rails" anywhere near the degree TPN did.