Forum - View topic

Confused. A cartoon is the same isn't it?

I think that there are five reasons why people don't like anime, and I'm in the mood to type it here (forgive me, I know none of this is "original thought"). There is a point; wait for it.

1: The predictable "watch one episode of DBZ or Pokemon and decide that it's stupid".

2: It could actually be too challenging for some of those who watch a typical American comedy. Now, I watch shows like Family Guy and the occasional Simpsons myself, and so I can tell you that there isn't a RULE here, certainly NOT.

3: Simple xenophobia.

4: Those who see others making a big deal out of it, and so decide that it MUST suck, even if they saw some before and liked it. This is not a theory, because I've seen several people admit to this.

5: There are of course people who... just don't like it. These people are usually quiet about it, though. They don't care about anime and don't care if people like it or not. The ignorant tend to yell the loudest, of course.

Someone summed it up pretty nicely in the G4 thread in the Talkback section.

Fiction Alchemist wrote:

I think that there are five reasons why people don't like anime, and I'm in the mood to type it here (forgive me, I know none of this is "original thought"). There is a point; wait for it. 1: The predictable "watch one episode of DBZ or Pokemon and decide that it's stupid". 2: It could actually be too challenging for some of those who watch a typical American comedy. Now, I watch shows like Family Guy and the occasional Simpsons myself, and so I can tell you that there isn't a RULE here, certainly NOT. 3: Simple xenophobia. 4: Those who see others making a big deal out of it, and so decide that it MUST suck, even if they saw some before and liked it. This is not a theory, because I've seen several people admit to this. 5: There are of course people who... just don't like it. These people are usually quiet about it, though. They don't care about anime and don't care if people like it or not. The ignorant tend to yell the loudest, of course.

Of course, a lot of people are convinced that most anime is hentai and consists of tentacle rape.

I dunno, it's pretty weird.

Even more baffling is the contempt for non-Japanese animation shown by anime fans. Surely they of all people should know better...?

Personally,I like anime better then American cartoons because theirs are more geared toward storyline rather then laughter. Americans usally want to laugh when then watch cartoons and they just do not understand anime

While the Simpson's may have a moral to the story, does the Family Guy, or is it used as an excuse to behave badly? And gee, why would Americans want to behave correctly? It is much more fashionable to be a pig, and make everyone else wallow in your slop, isn't it?

Sometimes I feel that certain anime are too depressing, have too much a defeatist attitude. But it beats being a slob is ok lesson by miles in my book. I like the "do your best", "I won't run away again" and all the other little morals that engender hope I find in most anime, which you just don't get from american cartoons, in general.

jaybug39 wrote:

While the Simpson's may have a moral to the story, does the Family Guy, or is it used as an excuse to behave badly? And gee, why would Americans want to behave correctly? It is much more fashionable to be a pig, and make everyone else wallow in your slop, isn't it? Sometimes I feel that certain anime are too depressing, have too much a defeatist attitude. But it beats being a slob is ok lesson by miles in my book. I like the "do your best", "I won't run away again" and all the other little morals that engender hope I find in most anime, which you just don't get from american cartoons, in general.

Watership Down, Secret of NIMH, Charlotte's Webb, Hey Arnold!, Batman: TAS, and a number of American animations want to have a word with you. NOW.

The Frankman wrote:

jaybug39 wrote: While the Simpson's may have a moral to the story, does the Family Guy, or is it used as an excuse to behave badly? And gee, why would Americans want to behave correctly? It is much more fashionable to be a pig, and make everyone else wallow in your slop, isn't it? Sometimes I feel that certain anime are too depressing, have too much a defeatist attitude. But it beats being a slob is ok lesson by miles in my book. I like the "do your best", "I won't run away again" and all the other little morals that engender hope I find in most anime, which you just don't get from american cartoons, in general. Watership Down, Secret of NIMH, Charlotte's Webb, Hey Arnold!, Batman: TAS, and a number of American animations want to have a word with you. NOW.

While what Frankman just listed some WONDERFUL animated movies, those are the exception rather than the norm for American animation. Like jaybug said: I'd rather watch someone trying to to their best even though they fail moreso than a tee-shirt, beer-bellied slob or the obnoxious foul-mouth kid.