Forum - View topicBest Supporting Character Tournament: Post-Mortem
|
Goto page Previous Next |
| Author | Message | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
rainbowcourage
 Posts: 1216 Location: what is commonly known as "hell week" |
|
|||||
Exactly. I'm still waiting for people who voted for Christopher over Lyuze to explain why. Because she should win this match, if we're talking relative merits. As for the Takumi match-up, I've only seen the first few episodes of Excel Saga, but I will say that nearly every second he's on the screen Takumi manages to wallop a new one at the viewer. This includes spoiler[getting Hachi pregnant, then, in a surprise reverse move asking her to marry him, separating the two protagonists, breaking up Hachi's relationship with Nobu, and generally turning her world upside down by making her suddenly rich and making her leave all her friends. All in the space of twenty odd episodes.] |
||||||
|
||||||
|
Key
Moderator
 Posts: 18460 Location: Indianapolis, IN (formerly Mimiho Valley) |
|
|||||
I did explain my reasoning in this post and feel no need to repeat myself. And while you two may think this is obvious, I don't see it that way. Admittedly, I only saw a handful of episodes of Casshern Sins, but Lyuze did not make that much of an impression on me - certainly not to the extent that Chris does in the same amount of time, anyway. Besides, Chris is hardly a borderline inclusion in this tournament; I'd even go as far as naming him one of the top contenders on the bottom side of the Group A bracket, given what all he does in SP. (Kimura certainly doesn't deserve to beat him, anyway.) Lyuze certainly sounds like a worthy opponent, and I'd probably buy the arguments for her against a lesser foe (i.e. almost anyone else on the bottom side of the group), but she had the misfortune of hitting a tough one in the first round. |
||||||
|
||||||
Sophisticat
 Posts: 165 |
|
|||||
|
Nabeshin vs. Takumi:
Nabeshin is great comedy relief. From his appearances in Excel to his cameo in Hayate, he's a very likable character who doesn't take much to get you laughing. Takumi, on the other hand, is very love/hate. He's definitely cool, but he can also be quite the bastard. Whether or not you want to stab him depends on your view of his actions. I don't think there's any clear superior contender here; it's down to preference. I voted for Takumi because I can relate to him in some ways and I just like characters like him. I don't think either contender in this match will go too far, so it probably doesn't matter who does win. |
||||||
|
||||||
|
rainbowcourage
Posts: 1216 Location: what is commonly known as "hell week" |
|
|||||
Yes, I read your reasoning, and of course Christopher is a worthy foe. But what you have to understand about CS is that for the first half it's an episodic journey--meaning it's focused on Casshern meeting various other characters. Lyuze is in the background of these episodes after her initial entrance--though it is she who initially questions Casshern's existence and new personality, and tells him that his amnesia is no absolution from his past. However (and I'm not sure which episodes you saw) Lyuze is much more important in the second half. She teaches Casshern about love, forgiveness, and ultimately, with spoiler[her death, she conveys to him exactly what every human and robot felt when the world was destroyed; he finally understands the full extent of his destruction and feels true remorse ], which in turn leads him to his final actions. She teaches him a wealth of other lessons, too, such as what it means to truly live. Casshern has always felt cursed by his immortal life, but in Lyuze's spoiler[final days, he learns what it's like to treasure each day one at a time. He experiences a kind of mortality for the first time, by watching his beloved die.] The point I'm making here is that people who have seen both series in their entirety are voting for Lyuze (admittedly, I haven't seen the last five episode of SP). If there's someone who has seen both and has a counterargument, I'd like to hear it. If not, this is a clearly a case of underexposure. |
||||||
|
||||||
LydiaDianne
 Posts: 5634 Location: Southern California |
|
|||||
So is Scrapped Princess. Where Pacifica goes around meeting various people, one of whom is Christopher and she changes HIS life, not the other way around. He questions why Pacifica spoiler[has to die] and in doing so, not only changes his life but the lives of his subordinates, as well as Prince Forsythe and Winia. Christopher is an honest and loyal man who discovers that he and the people he has sworn to protect have been lied to for millenia and sets out to do what he can to rectify the situation. |
||||||
|
||||||
NGE1113
 Posts: 1081 Location: Alexandria, VA. |
|
|||||
|
Group A-1
Maes Hughes, Fullmetal Alchemist franchise Group A-2 Eri Ninamori, FLCL Group A-3 Haruka Tenoh/Sailor Uranus, Sailor Moon Group A-4 Toki, Princess Mononoke Group A-5 Nabuca, Now and Then, Here and There Group A-6 Mendoza, The Mysterious Cities of Gold Group A-7 Genkai, Yu Yu Hakusho Group A-8 Nana, Elfen Lied Group A-9 Lt. Yamamoto The Irresponsible Captain Tylor Group A-10 Lyuze, Casshern Sins Group A-11 Kimura, Azumanga Daioh Group A-12 Edel, Princess Tutu Group A-13 Alex Rowe, Last Exile Group A-14 Jung Freud, Gunbuster Group A-15 Ushio Okazaki, Clannad After Story Group A-16 Nabeshin, Excel Saga, et al. |
||||||
|
||||||
Ggultra2764
 Subscriber Posts: 3969 Location: New York state. |
|
|||||
|
I don't get it with Match A-4. Itoko provided both advice and torment to Harima who's a major character yet Toki doesn't really do much to impact Princess Mononoke. What has many folks voting for her?
|
||||||
|
||||||
|
Key
Moderator
Posts: 18460 Location: Indianapolis, IN (formerly Mimiho Valley) |
|
|||||
|
Round 1 Group A is now closed.
Final results as follows: A-1: Maes Hughes def. Yue Ayase 31-1 A-2: Eri Ninamori def. Naru Osaka 23-9 A-3: Haruka Tenoh def. Setsuna 29-3 A-4: Toki def. Itoko Osakabe 18-14 A-5: Nabuca def. Neya 25-7 A-6: Kazuko Yoshiyama def. Mendoza 21-11 A-7: Genkai def. Rick Thunderbolt 18-14 A-8: Nana def. Olivier Mira Armstrong 19-13 A-9: Lt. Yamamoto def. Tetsu 24-8 A-10: Christopher Armalite def. Lyuze 19-13 A-11: Kimura def. Satoshi Miwa 23-9 A-12: Edel def. Oji-san 25-7 A-13: Alex Rowe def. Reiko Natsume 24-8 A-14: Renge Hoshakuji def. Jung Freud 22-10 A-15: Ushio Okazaki def. Lory Takarada 24-8 A-16: Nabeshin def. Takumi 18-14 Yes, I know this is a new format for doing this, but I'm going to try it for a couple of groups and see how I like it. Anyway, out of 32 votes we had five matches won with less than 60% of the vote total and only two that were total blow-outs. I suspect that future rounds will continue to be fairly tight. Next round should be up in a few minutes. |
||||||
|
||||||
|
Key
Moderator
Posts: 18460 Location: Indianapolis, IN (formerly Mimiho Valley) |
|
|||||
|
Round 1 Group B is now closed.
Results can be found here. Nothing fancy this time; let's just get to business! Group B-1 Balalaika, Black Lagoon vs. Elfriede, Moon Phase Group B-2 Akira Ferrari, Aria franchise vs. November 11, Darker Than Black Group B-3 Franz d’Epinay, Gankutsuou: The Count of Monte Cristo vs. Dryden Fassa, The Vision of Escaflowne Group B-4 Fred Lou, Outlaw Star vs. Shihoun Yoruichi, Bleach Group B-5 Dr. Reichwein, Monster vs. Jack Vessalius, Pandora Hearts Group B-6 Kurz Weber, Full Metal Panic! franchise vs. Kittan Bachika, Gurren Lagann Group B-7 Shikamaru, Naruto franchise vs. Yashima, Kamichu! Group B-8 Roy Focker, Super Dimension Fortress Macross vs. Toya Kinomoto/Tori Avalon, Cardcaptor Sakura/Cardcaptors Group B-9 Ichiro Mihara, Angelic Layer vs. Kanami Yuta, sCRYed Group B-10 Winry Rockbell, Fullmetal Alchemist franchise vs. Hiroshi Uchiyamada, Great Teacher Onizuka Group B-11 Cornelia li Britannia, Code Geass vs. Shuichi Natori, Natsume’s Book of Friends Group B-12 Hosaka, Minami-ke vs. Komui Lee, D-Gray Man Group B-13 Leopold Scorpse, Scrapped Princess vs. Kurotowa, Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind Group B-14 Walter von Schenkopp, Legend of the Galactic Heroes franchise vs. Reika Mishima, RahXephon Group B-15 Letopanyu Spoor, Crest/Banner of the Stars franchise vs. Tatiana Wisla, Last Exile Group B-16 Misaki Kirihara, Darker Than Black franchise vs. Torioi Kiyori, Sasemeki Koto Last edited by Key on Mon May 03, 2010 11:11 pm; edited 1 time in total |
||||||
|
||||||
|
LydiaDianne
Posts: 5634 Location: Southern California |
|
|||||
|
Group B-1
Balalaika, Black Lagoon Group B-2 November 11, Darker Than Black Group B-3 Dryden Fassa, The Vision of Escaflowne Group B-4 Shihoun Yoruichi, Bleach Group B-5 Dr. Reichwein, Monster Group B-6 Kurz Weber, Full Metal Panic! franchise Group B-7 Shikamaru, Naruto franchise Group B-8 Toya Kinomoto/Tori Avalon, Cardcaptor Sakura/Cardcaptors Group B-9 Ichiro Mihara, Angelic Layer This one is hard because I like both characters but I’m going with Icchan because of the “weird (perverted?) scientist factor and because he loves spoiler[Misaki’s mother and wants the two of them to be together and happy and is willing to manipulate Misaki to attain that goal.] Group B-10 Winry Rockbell, Fullmetal Alchemist franchise Group B-11 Cornelia li Britannia, Code Geass Group B-12 Komui Lee, D-Gray Man Group B-13 Leopold Scorpse, Scrapped Princess Group B-14 Reika Mishima, RahXephon Group B-15 Tatiana Wisla, Last Exile This one was difficult, as well, because I like both characters very much but I’m going to go with Tatiana for now, because of her “fall” and subsequent “rise.” Group B-16 Misaki Kirihara, Darker Than Black franchise |
||||||
|
||||||
|
dtm42
Posts: 14084 Location: currently stalking my waifu |
|
|||||
|
All my votes are not set in stone, as they really just reflect my Minigame picks. I am willing to change them if I see good arguments for the other side. So please try your best to persuade me.
Group B-1 Balalaika, Black Lagoon vs. Elfriede, Moon Phase Balalaika Group B-2 Akira Ferrari, Aria franchise vs. November 11, Darker Than Black November 11 Group B-3 Franz d’Epinay, Gankutsuou: The Count of Monte Cristo vs. Dryden Fassa, The Vision of Escaflowne Franz Group B-4 Fred Lou, Outlaw Star vs. Shihoun Yoruichi, Bleach Fred Group B-5 Dr. Reichwein, Monster vs. Jack Vessalius, Pandora Hearts Jack Group B-6 Kurz Weber, Full Metal Panic! franchise vs. Kittan Bachika, Gurren Lagann Kittan Group B-7 Shikamaru, Naruto franchise vs. Yashima, Kamichu! Shikamaru Group B-8 Roy Focker, Super Dimension Fortress Macross vs. Toya Kinomoto/Tori Avalon, Cardcaptor Sakura/Cardcaptors Roy Group B-9 Ichiro Mihara, Angelic Layer vs. Kanami Yuta, sCRYed Ichiro Group B-10 Winry Rockbell, Fullmetal Alchemist franchise vs. Hiroshi Uchiyamada, Great Teacher Onizuka Winry Group B-11 Cornelia li Britannia, Code Geass vs. Shuichi Natori, Natsume’s Book of Friends Cornelia Group B-12 Hosaka, Minami-ke vs. Komui Lee, D-Gray Man Komui Group B-13 Leopold Scorpse, Scrapped Princess vs. Kurotowa, Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind Leopold Group B-14 Walter von Schenkopp, Legend of the Galactic Heroes franchise vs. Reika Mishima, RahXephon Reika Despite my personal dislike of Von Schenkopp and the massive plot armour he carried around with him, I will admit that he did do quite a bit in Legend of the Galactic Heroes. He was insightful and even funny, and he made some big plot breakthroughs. He is not a weak candidate. However, RahXephon simply couldn't have worked without Reika. She was an integral part, as she made a heck of a lot happen, both story-wise and in terms of the characters' respective arcs. If anyone wants to know more, I'd be happy to give a run down of her achievements. It's quite a list. Looked at dispassionately, she is clearly the superior contender here. Group B-15 Letopanyu Spoor, Crest/Banner of the Stars franchise vs. Tatiana Wisla, Last Exile Spoor Group B-16 Misaki Kirihara, Darker Than Black franchise vs. Torioi Kiyori, Sasemeki Koto Misaki Last edited by dtm42 on Tue Apr 27, 2010 1:18 am; edited 1 time in total |
||||||
|
||||||
zawa113
 Posts: 7358 |
|
|||||
|
Well, certainly sad to not see Mendoza move on, I really do chalk this up to almost no one having seen MCOG. Even I was torn between Rick and Genkai, so I certainly plan to support her for a while now.
B-1: Elfriede B-2: Akira Ferrari B-3: Franz d'Epinay I've seen all of Escaflowne and part of Gankutsuou, I don't even recall Dryden to be honest despite having actually finished that series. B-4: Yoruichi I've always felt Fred Lou to be comic relief first, supporting Gene second. Vote Change: B-5: Jack Arguments have convinced me that Dr. Reichwein is from a more popular series but not necessarily as necessary to the story or other characters as Jack. B-6: Kittan B-7: Shikamaru B-8: Roy Fokker I've seen Robotech and read Card Captor Sakura. This is an easy one for me, Toya acts like a good big brother when absolutely needed, but the story honestly barely calls for him. On the other hand, Roy's influence is always there even if he isn't. B-9: Ichiro Mihara B-10: Winry Rockbell Believe or not, Uchiyamda defends Onizuka working at Holy Forest Academy. In the manga. B-11: Shuichi Natori Vote Change: B-12: Hosaka Aside from not having actually seen either series, arguments have convinced me that Hosaka deserves to move on more and since I've no personal connection to either character, I think I'll go for the one with some actual backing behind him. The fact that everyone who voted for him is shocked he's losing seems a bit suspicious to me too. B-13: Leopold Scorpse B-14: Walter von Schenkopp Everyone who has seen the series should know why I vote for him. After a point, Julian also joins the Rosenritters and Walter von Schenkopp is a great mentor to him, as well as a badass. B-15: Letopanyu Spoor I felt Tatiana was more a rival than actually useful as a supporting. B-16: Torioi Kiyori Last edited by zawa113 on Mon May 03, 2010 9:54 am; edited 3 times in total |
||||||
|
||||||
|
Ggultra2764
Subscriber Posts: 3969 Location: New York state. |
|
|||||
|
Match B-1: Balalaika (Black Lagoon)
Match B-2: Akira Ferrari (Aria) Match B-3: Franz d'Epinay (Gankutsuou) The fact Franz is acquainted with the Count from what I've heard of the series has me going for Franz. Match B-4: Shihouin Yoruichi (Bleach) Helped trained Ichigo's friends on perfecting their powers and plays a major role in helping Ichigo's group out during the Soul Society arc. A lot more involvement than Fred's weapon supplying and comic relief. Match B-5: Dr. Richwein (Monster) The good doctor does enough to aid Tenma, gather information and having to look after those Tenma has rescued. Match B-6: Kruz Weber (Full Metal Panic) Match B-7: Shikamaru (Naruto) Match B-8: Roy Focker (Macross) Match B-9: Kanami Yuta (s-Cry-ed) spoiler[Her influence on Kazuma and Ryuho throughout the series lead the two to later set aside their rivalry to deal with a bigger threat.] Match B-10: Winry Rockbell (Full Metal Alchemist) Surrogate sister, automail mechanic and wrench-tossing fiend for Ed and Al. Match B-11: Cornelia li Britannia (Code Geass) Match B-12: Komui Lee (D-Gray Man) Match B-13: Leopold Scorpse (Scrapped Princess) Match B-14: Reika Mishima (RahXephon) Her very influence is what starts off Ayato's search for the truth of his existence. Match B-15: Tatiana Wisla (Last Exile) Match B-16: Misaki Kirihara (Darker than Black) |
||||||
|
||||||
marie-antoinette
 Posts: 4136 Location: Ottawa, Canada |
|
|||||
|
Group B-1
Voting for:Balalaika, Black Lagoon Group B-2 Voting for:November 11, Darker Than Black Group B-3 Voting for:Dryden Fassa, The Vision of Escaflowne Oh, this is a match-up that hurts. I so want to vote for both of them yet, of course, I can't. So in the end I'm going with Dryden on the basis that I nominated him. But this is another match-up where either would be fine to me as a winner. Group B-4 Voting for:Shihoun Yoruichi, Bleach Group B-5 Voting for:Dr. Reichwein, Monster Group B-6 Voting for:Kurz Weber, Full Metal Panic! franchise Group B-7 Voting for:Shikamaru, Naruto franchise Group B-8 Voting for:Toya Kinomoto/Tori Avalon, Cardcaptor Sakura/Cardcaptors Group B-9 Voting for:Ichiro Mihara, Angelic Layer Group B-10 Voting for:Winry Rockbell, Fullmetal Alchemist franchise Group B-11 Voting for:Cornelia li Britannia, Code Geass Group B-12 Voting for:Hosaka, Minami-ke Group B-13 Voting for:Kurotowa, Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind Group B-14 Voting for:Reika Mishima, RahXephon This reminds me that I always wanted to watch RahXephon. Group B-15 Voting for:Letopanyu Spoor, Crest/Banner of the Stars franchise Group B-16 Voting for:Misaki Kirihara, Darker Than Black franchise |
||||||
|
||||||
Generic #757858
 Posts: 1354 |
|
|||||
|
Group B-1: Balalaika
Group B-2: November 11 Group B-3: Franz d’Epinay Group B-4: Fred Lou Group B-5: Dr. Reichwein Group B-6: Kittan Bachika Group B-7: Yashima Group B-8: Roy Focker Group B-9: Kanami Yuta Group B-10: Winry Rockbell Group B-11: Shuichi Natori Group B-12: Komui Lee Group B-13: Kurotowa Group B-14: Reika Mishima Group B-15: Letopanyu Spoor Group B-16: Torioi Kiyori |
||||||
|
||||||
 |
All times are GMT - 5 Hours |
|
|
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group